Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Huckleberry Finn

The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a thrilling and complex novel. It seems to have it all: well-developed characters, original adventures, detailed settings, humor, and a deep theme. No wonder Mark Twain is called the "greatest American humorist of his age" and considered one of the best American authors ever.

The characters in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn are interesting and well-developed. The Duke and the King are the most fascinating of them all. The Duke and the King are like Professor Lockhart in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. Besides their obvious similarity in all being con men, there are many more comparisons. In both books, the reader immediately knows they are fakes, as do the main characters, Huck and Harry. Although it is so obvious to us and to some characters, the majority of the people are fooled by their act. Also, although both Huck and Harry know about them being con men, they do not try to expose them. Huck does reveal the Duke and King's true nature, but most of the time he, like Harry, is just astounded by people's gullibility, not caring if people see the truth.

The scene at the Phelps's house is very unrealistic. Huck Finn is usually plausible and only fantastical in character's extreme actions. The scene with the Phelps does not follow that plot line. The fact that the family who imprisons Jim happens to be Tom Sawyer's family and he is about to visit is just too many coincidences. Other events in the story are spectacular, but they could happen to anyone if sought out. However, pretending to be the Phelps's relative, Tom Sawyer,whom Huck knows everything about,is just too much unbelievable luck.

I really do not like people's attitude to black people back then, especially Huck's. People in the pre-Civil War era treated blacks like dirt because of their bigotry and greed, and then had the audacity to teach them "Christian Ways." Huck disappointed me because I thought a boy in his situation would have more sympathy and understanding for Negros. He lived most of his life thought of as less than a person. In The Adventures of Tom Sawyer he was thought of as a cretin, a son of a drunk. Yet he rose above these circumstances and became a person that when thought dead many respected people searched for and mourned him. He of all people should understand that even if others did not think so, Jim was a human. Even though he noticed endless similarities between white and black men, he still did not see the truth because of generations of bigotry. He even called the slaves and his friends the offensive nigger. He constantly thought he would go to Hell because he helped a man or as he called it stealing Miss Watson's "property". I am frustrated that Huck in such a similar place could not empathize with a runaway slave.

The theme of the story is striving for a better life, as that is what all the characters pursued. Even if they went about it the wrong way, it is what drove them to keep fighting. This is human nature. The Duke and the King believed money is what made life better, so that is what they fought for. Pap believed power and booze were the keys to happiness, and thus drank and exerted his power over anyone he could. Since Huck was the only one that abided it, he received the worst of Pap's dominion. Pap still tried to control others like Judge Thatcher, who he tried to force to give up Huck's money. Jim improved his life by running away, because what quality of life could you possibly have if you are not free. Huck strove for the impossible, what would indeed be the perfect living; fun and complete freedom, yet still being cared for and looked after. He did not find it, but instead settled for being wanted and looked after. Huckleberry Finn is a layered book. The first layer is an exiciting adventure, second is the political and economic issues of the time, and third is an accurate and scathing portrayal of the nature of humans and what defines human nature.

6 comments:

  1. Quite interesting book so far. After reading Tom Sawyer, I think this book is going to draw me in closer.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like your comparison with Harry Potter. That's a good way to think about it, and I agree. But I don't feel the same about Huck's view of blacks. I agree that it was wrong and digusting how blacks and slaves were treated, but Huck doesn't really know any better. He was just following the crowd and treating them the only way he knew how. Huck eventually learns to see Jim as a human being, but you have to recall the time period this story was set in. I think Mark Twain was smart to not gloss over anything like that. But otherwise, I did like the book.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with most of your blog and the price thing is funny; but I do disasgree that Huck chose a friendship over the law. I mean, technically he did but he knew deep down he did not agree that all blacks were dispicable and lower than whites. I do agree with you that his close friendship with Jim was one of the core reasons for his dangerous actions throught the book.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh and I just wanted to say I completely agree with Brandi's comment above. Huck started out questioning his actions and what he was going to do next and said " He would just have to go to hell" because treating blacks as property was all he knew. My history teacher this past year told us that i the history we are tought in school has an American spin on it. So like when Germans are being taught about WWII theyr'e is a German spin.

    ReplyDelete
  5. lol sorry! meaning this is all they know, therefor to them its what is right.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think Kathleen hit the nail right on the head in saying that black people were treated like dirt back then. Racism is seen a lot in this novel. You cannot really say Huck did not know any better because not everybody was racist back then. People in the North disagreed with slavery and racism so much back then that they went into war over it. Sure there was segregation in the North, but there was not slavery. Not everybody in the South was racist, so Huck had to at least seen one person treat an African-American as an equal during some period in his life in the South. I am sure Huck was not naive to the idea that African-Americans should be treated equally.

    I have never read any Harry Potter books so I cannot comment on the comparison, but I do not believe that the Duke and the King are the most fascinating characters. I do not think the con men are fascinating because they are people who are looking to make a fast buck any way they can by stealing money from people. They even pretend to be the uncles of the orphaned girls, trying to steal the money that is rightfully the girls. This is a sick scheme and I am glad it did not work out for the con men. Maybe if I knew what the comparison about Harry Potter was about, I might believe the Duke and the King were the most fascinating. My advice to you Kathleen is to make a comparison that everybody knows, maybe from a book we read in Honors 9 or something like that. Other than that I really liked how you interpreted the book.

    ReplyDelete